Cookies

BUTTERCOOKY BAKERY & CAFE

MANHASSET

LONG ISLAND FAMILY-OWNED AND OPERATED
FOR OVER 50 YEARS

FRESH BAKED PASTRIES, COOKIES, CUSTOM CAKES, AND SO MUCH MORE

as seen in

1280px-Newsday.svg.png
1459875931_zagat-logo.png
HNlogoshrunk.webp
2563092_orig.png
Manhasset_WebLogo-544-x-180-300x99.jpg
photo%20jul%2030%2C%201%2002%2047%20am_e

STAY A WHILE

OR TAKE IT TO GO!

SAVOR OUR BUTTERCOOKY CAFE MENU

Baked with butter makes it better.

Words to live by. 

For over 50 years our family has served Long Island's sweetest memories.

Our bakeries in Floral Park, Manhasset, and Huntington are all still family owned and operated, with the same dedication to excellence, family, and community that we have had since we opened our doors.

photo%20jan%2012%2C%202%2043%2052%20am_e
photo%20jul%2030%2C%201%2057%2031%20am%2
photo sep 24, 1 38 09 am.jpg

AS SEEN ON
THE KNOT

See what our customers are saying about us on
the Knot

CALL US AT (516) 627-1600

LOCATED AT 140 PLANDOME ROAD, MANHASSET, NY 11030

BAKED WITH BUTTER, MAKES IT BETTER

follow us @buttercooky_bakery to see what we're

baking up!