OUR STORY
A family’s passion. A tradition of craftsmanship. A place in Long Island’s sweetest memories.
Behind Buttercooky Bakery & Cafe is a family whose lives have been shaped by baking, hospitality, and the pride of building something together.
For Ben Borgognone, that passion began at an early age in a Brooklyn bakery. Working his way through the business, from serving customers to decorating cakes, he developed the discipline, creativity, and attention to detail that would become the foundation of his career.
His journey later brought him to Manhattan’s Plaza Hotel as an assistant pastry chef, where he deepened his appreciation for French pastry, and to the celebrated Veniero’s in the East Village. Combining his Italian baking roots with European pastry techniques, Ben developed a style that honors tradition while leaving room for imagination.
In 1995, Ben and his wife purchased Buttercooky Bakery in Floral Park, a neighborhood institution established in 1962. Together, they began a new chapter, preserving its familiar character while bringing their own vision to its future.
Ben’s wife has been part of that journey from the beginning. As both his partner and the mother of their three children, her place in Buttercooky’s story connects the business they built with the family at its heart. Their shared commitment helped establish a foundation that their children now carry forward.
Today, Francesco, Benny Jr., and Alyssa Borgognone each have a place in that continuing story. With the family involved across generations, Buttercooky remains deeply personal—a reflection of the people behind it and the communities it serves.
Benny Jr. brings that family commitment to Manhasset, helping carry his father’s vision forward on Plandome Road. His involvement connects the next generation of the Borgognone family with a community that has embraced Buttercooky since the location opened in 2005.
Francesco has helped shape Buttercooky’s Huntington chapter, playing an important role alongside his father when the location opened in 2017 and helping develop its bakery-and-café experience. It is a place where customers can stop for their favorite pastries, gather for breakfast or lunch, and settle in over coffee.
Their sister, Alyssa, is also part of the family business, contributing to the next chapter alongside her parents and brothers. Her involvement makes this a story shared by the entire family, with each member bringing their own perspective and care to Buttercooky’s future.
Across Floral Park, Manhasset, and Huntington, that family spirit takes on a distinct neighborhood character.
Floral Park is our original home—the bakery where our family’s Buttercooky journey began. Manhasset carries that tradition into the heart of its community. Huntington brings our baking heritage together with a welcoming sit-down café. Each location has its own personality, united by the same pride in what we make and how we welcome you.
Our cases tell another part of the story: fresh croissants and Danish, artisan breads, butter cookies, delicate French pastries, homemade pies, signature cakes, and custom creations for life’s biggest celebrations. Behind them is the belief that has guided our family’s approach from the start: exceptional baking begins with ingredients worth caring about.
BAKED WITH BUTTER, MAKES IT BETTER.
For us, the greatest reward is knowing where our work goes—onto your holiday tables, into your birthday celebrations, beside your morning coffee, and into traditions passed down within your own families.
From our family to yours, thank you for making Buttercooky part of your story.
